The Best Sump Pumps for 2024

Best Sump Pumps - Top Picks, Reviews & Complete Buying Guide

A sump pump is not something that people buy frequently, but it is more and more used when houses are built.

If you are reading this, then you are certainly in need of one.

Choosing the right sump pump can take a pretty much time doing a research among the models offered on the market.

That is why, we are offering you a list of the top quality sump pumps and all the information you should have in mind when purchasing one.

Spoiler Alert - Check out my top choice here >>

Top Rated Sump Pumps

Model Rating Buy Now
WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Sump PumpWAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Sump Pump
Check Price
Superior Pump 91250Superior Pump 91250
Check Price
Wayne ESP25 Battery Backup Sump PumpWayne ESP25 Battery Backup Sump Pump
Check Price
Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump PumpZoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump
Check Price
Superior Pump 92341 Sump PumpSuperior Pump 92341 Sump Pump
Check Price
* Ratings are based on Editor's own opinion.

5 Best Sump Pumps Reviewed

#1. WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Sump Pump

Top Pick
WAYNE CDU980E 3/4 HP Sump Pump
Check Price on Amazon

Number one sump pump on our list is the Wayne CDU980E.

It is a model which can move up to 4600 gallons per hour.

The Wayne CDU980E’s producers thought about the debris, which is filtered due to the top suction design available.

Furthermore, the design was not neglected, which makes this submersible sump pump reasonably the high-quality one.

To make the engine more durable, they have made the motor of stainless steel which is corrosion resistant and the machine boasts with the 2HP motor which makes it good value for money.

The pump base is made of cast iron and the material on the handle of the pump is a stainless steel, making it much more portable.

The weakness is that the handle is little.

However, in case of high water pressure and collisions with objects, the product is capable of withstanding.

Its design is aimed at sump pits that are at least 11 inches in diameter and the product is fully submersible.

When we speak about the switch, which is an important part of every sump pump, we can say that it is highly responsive and has a guard to protect it from damage.

Additionally, the power cord is fully submersible, but short.

All in all, this is definitely the best of the best sump pumps available.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Great capacity
  • Quality material
  • Switch


  • Small handle
  • Short cable
Check Price on Amazon

#2. Superior Pump 91250

Superior Pump 91250
Check Price on Amazon

The Superior Pump 91250 has a 1/4 HP motor with great power and is completely worth the price.

It is a submersible utility pump, capable of pumping up to 30 gallons per minute and 25 vertical feet upwards.

There is a small, but durable, thermoplastic frame whose aim is to protect the pump from corrosion.

What makes this pump the best is definitely the fact that it can run for a long period of time without any problems.

It is very versatile, meaning that it can be used whenever and wherever you want.

There is a switch which can automatically turn off the pump or you can do it manually by yourself.

When you are having issues related to draining still water from swimming pools and fountains or flooded basements, this is the ideal pump for those tasks.

The Superior Pump 91250 is fully submersible and has long water resistant power cord made of hard material, so consumers find it that cord is not flexible enough.

The performance is excellent and the engine is very quiet when working.

The lack of a float switch is considered a drawback, but you can always add it and use the machine as a sump pump.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Not loud while working
  • Versatile


  • Cord is not flexible
  • Lacks float switch
Check Price on Amazon

#3. Wayne ESP25 Battery Backup Sump Pump

Wayne ESP25 Battery Backup Sump Pump
Check Price on Amazon

It can be very troublesome if your sump pump fails you when it is the most necessary.


That is why the producers of the Wayne ESP25 thought about the possibility of this issue and created this model making it the best battery backup sump pump.

The main goal of manufacturers was to create a pump which will be used in emergency situations when there is no power.

So, with this model, failure is not an option.

It boasts a 1/3 HP motor which can be used as a backup for any sump pump and it is able to pump 2,300 gallons of water per hour.

There is a float switch, as well, and no need to connect it to your existing sump pumps.

The Wayne ESP25 has the thermoplastic housing which durable and the model is completely waterproof.

We should mention some additional excellent features, such as the fact that it is on a quiet side when in operation and it is easy to install.

On the other hand, there are certain weaknesses, including the short battery cable and short charger cord being and the lack of an alarm reset button.

The alarm is not so loud, and it can cause you issues if you are no able to hear when it starts.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Power
  • Quiet


  • Short cables
  • Lack of alarm reset
Check Price on Amazon

#4. Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump

Zoeller M53 Mighty-mate Submersible Sump Pump
Check Price on Amazon

The first thought that comes into our mind when we see the Zoeller M53 is huge and green.

The producers did not pay too much attention to its appearance, but as it goes to your basement, it does not matter at all.

They have put much effort to make a durable product of cast iron housing on top of a thermoplastic base.

It weighs a lot, but its advantage is the ability of running long hours without causing an issue.

Among great number of submersible sump pump, the M53 Mighty-Mate respectfully deserves its position on this list, as it is efficient and can manage 45 gallons of water per minute and even 2700 gallons per hour.

It can be very useful when clearing water from a sump pit or from a pool, and if you thought that it is noisy due to its largeness, you are wrong.

This pump is surprisingly quiet.

One drawback that is attributed to this pump is the quality of the float switch causing that small water jobs cannot be done with it.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Durability
  • Power


  • Switch is not of good quality
  • Not useful for small water
Check Price on Amazon

#5. Superior Pump 92341 Sump Pump

Superior Pump 92341 Sump Pump
Check Price on Amazon

Even though it is the last on our list, it does not mean that it is not worth mentioning.

Quite contrary, the Superior Pump 92341 is the model with both housing and base made of cast iron, meaning that it was created to be durable and life-long.

The material of which other parts of this sump pump are made is stainless steel.

The Superior Pump 92341 is a versatile 1/3 hp submersible sump pump.

It boasts with an automatic on/off vertical float switch that can be easily removed, thus causing the pump to become a utility pump for small water tasks.

Its capacity is moving up of 46 gallons of water per minute or 2760 gallons per hour.

Its motor is thermally protected and intended to provide the Superior Pump 92341 as much durability as possible.

Its design is such that the pump fits well in narrow sump basins.

When you look at it, you will think that it is such a noisy machine, due to its appearance, but quite contrary, it is really quiet when in operation.

The disadvantage is that some parts got rusted and people had issues with the unit failing altogether.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Ideally used as a utility pump
  • Great for small sump basins


  • Parts get rusted
Check Price on Amazon

Sump Pumps: The Ultimate Buying Guide

If you need to decide which kind of sump pump you need for your home, here you will get all the necessary information.

Sump Pump

What are the types of pump available?

When it comes to pump types, two types can be taken into consideration: pedestal and submersible.

Both pumps have advantages as well as a few disadvantages:

  • Submersible – When somebody mentions a sump pump, the first one to come into your mind is the submersible on, as those are the most common sump pumps. As its name suggests, this sump pump is submerged underwater in your sump pit when the house is built. Their containers are waterproof and as they are set in the sump basin, there is more space on your basement floor for some other things. Great advantage is that they do not make much noise as the motor is in the water. They are more powerful than pedestal sump pumps, meaning that they pump water faster and this makes them ideal for emergency situations. You can also have a backup battery to be used when there is the power outrage. As it has so many advantages, submersible sump pumps are more expensive. When it comes to repairing, these types of pump are difficult to be accessed.
  • Pedestal – The second type of sump pumps are less expensive pedestal sump pumps. They come in two pieces – the standalone motor located on or above the basement floor and the hose/shaft which feeds into the sump pit. With this type of pump, the motor is not in the water, so the overheating can happen and this should be taken into consideration when choosing the pump. On the other hand, the water damage is rarely possible, as the motor is above ground. Pedestal sump pumps are designed for shallow or narrow sump pits and being that they are above the water, you can repair them easily if necessary. When it comes to power, pedestal sump pumps are not as powerful as submersible sump pumps. Furthermore, they take more basement space.

What should I take into consideration before buying a pump?

Making a decision is a difficult job to do, especially if there are so many opportunities to choose from.

When it comes to sump pumps, we understand that you are not sure which one to buy, considering the fact that many producers offer pumps with similar features and almost equal prices.

This additional information may help you decide:

  • Switch – The type of switch has the impact on the durability of the product. The switch should not be hitting the basin wall or any other obstruction. There are three types of switches: tethered, vertical and electronic. Tethered switches provide longer period of working as well as the small number of rest times, but require a larger sump pit. Vertical switches are designed for narrow sump pits but fewer rest times between cycles are necessary. There are no moving parts in Electronic switches, meaning that they cannot get stuck, but the cleaning of the electronic probes is obligatory.
  • Horsepower – Horsepower determines the power of your sump pump, and the more it has, the faster it can move water. However, the more powerful they are, the price is quite higher and the electricity usage is greater. The amount of horsepower you need depends on the area of drainage, the depth to the groundwater and the depth of the basement and the average level is a 1/3 hp pump. If you cannot determine the amount of horsepower you need, it is better to buy a more powerful one, than realizing that it is weak after the purchase.
  • Housing-  Those durable and a long time sump pumps are usually made of strong materials. You should think about those materials that should not rust or break easily. If you are planning an extended usage of this pump then thermoplastic pumps should not be on your list. Pumps made of this material are the cheapest and lightest, but prone to cracking. The second material is stainless steel which does not rust but it is quite heavy The ideal solution is cast iron as it does not break easily, it is heavier than thermoplastic and is not as heavy as stainless steel.

Sump Pump

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions is the section which can be very useful if there are still some unanswered questions.

Which one is better: a pedestal or submersible pump?

There isn’t a specific proven fact which will show how one type is better than the other.

Which one will be better for you depend on your specific needs as they are designed for different types of work.

Pedestal sump pumps are more affordable, but not as quick and efficient as submersible pumps which are more expensive.

Furthermore, the size of the sump pump pit can also determine which type is better for you.

What is the average horsepower that a good sump pump should have?

If your pump has more horsepower it means that it can move water faster and more efficiently.

However, if the amount of water accumulated in the basin is not great, then a lower horsepower pump would be good for that task.

In case of flooding emergencies the more powerful pump which will fit in the basin is a must.

Does the material of which the sump pump is made of play a vital role?

As there are sump pumps made of various materials, such as cast iron, stainless steel, and thermoplastic, offered on the market, it is difficult to decide which one is the best.

However, if you want a pump which will be strong and durable, you should think about those made of cast iron or stainless steel, with only disadvantage that parts can become rusted.

On the other hand, thermoplastic sump pumps are cheaper and resistant to rust, but are not as strong and durable.

Is the sump basin size important?

In this case, it is.

The bigger is better with sump basins.

This is due to the fact that pump cycles can then be longer.

The size of the basin would determine which type of sump pump you are going buy in terms of the pump switch, because its hitting the sides of the basin and breaking is not acceptable and reasonable.


It is true that making a decision which sump pump to buy takes time, effort and can be very troublesome.

But, if you really need it, it is better to make this decision as soon as possible so as prevent costly damage.

In order to help you choose well, we offered you a list of advantages and disadvantages of both pedestal and submersible sump pumps.

Now, that you possess the right information, everything is on you.

As the need for sump pumps have increased in the recent years, the result of this is a wide number of sump pump producers who are offering great products at almost equal prices.

So, do not postpone your decision, as you never know when the emergency situation might happen when you will need a sump pump.

I hope you liked my article about Sump Pumps, if so, please share or comment.

Leave a Comment

Get information about programs near you or online.