The Best 23-Gauge Pin Nailers for 2024

Best 23-Gauge Pin Nailers - Top Picks, Reviews & Complete Buying Guide

The experienced workers know when they should use a pin nailer and when a brad nailer is the ideal solution.

Pinners are used in cases where glue would be used to join two pieces of lightweight wood together.

The pins are ideal being that there are no heads and they become virtually invisible on the surface after it is painted or treated.

Now, as we know that determining which pin nailer is the best for you can be troublesome, we have done the research which included the examination of the various models and made this list of reviews to help you make the right decision.

Spoiler Alert - Check out my top choice here >>

Top Rated 23-Gauge Pin Nailers

Model Rating Buy Now
Hitachi NP35A Pin NailerHitachi NP35A Pin Nailer
Check Price
BOSTITCH HP118K 23-Gauge Pin Nail GunBOSTITCH HP118K 23-Gauge Pin Nail Gun
Check Price
Freeman PP123 23 Gauge Pin NailerFreeman PP123 23 Gauge Pin Nailer
Check Price
NuMax SP123 Pin Nail-GunNuMax SP123 Pin Nail-Gun
Check Price
Makita AF353 Pinning NailerMakita AF353 Pinning Nailer
Check Price
* Ratings are based on Editor's own opinion.

5 Best 23-Gauge Pin Nailers Reviewed

#1. Hitachi NP35A Pin Nailer

Top Pick
Hitachi NP35A Pin Nailer
Check Price on Amazon

When we speak about the best of the best, we concluded that our top pick has a lot to show.

This is this two-pound Hitachi pin nailer which offers the effortless pin loading, which does not jam and is comfortable to hold and use.

Additionally, it comes with a good range of fasteners that you can use.

Plus, you get a nice dual trigger safety and the rear exhaust port which directs oil and other debris away from you.

The users say that the wrench for making depth adjustments is stored right on the tool.

This is considered ideal as you will not have to hunt around for it prior to the depth change

The manufacturer offers five-year warranty and you can be sure that buying this model would not make you regret.

The result is a pin nailer with little or no impact, great flush pinning, and hardly any marring of the material.

What we did not like about this model is the case which looks good but is very cheap and flimsy.

Besides this, this nailer is definitely the winner.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Dual trigger safety
  • Five-year warranty period
  • Light
  • No jams
  • Great


  • Cheap case
Check Price on Amazon

#2. BOSTITCH HP118K 23-Gauge Pin Nail Gun

BOSTITCH HP118K 23-Gauge Pin Nail Gun
Check Price on Amazon

We will compare our second best with the Hitachi pin nailer.

The Bostitch model is light and comfortable to hold and use.

Just like our top pick it does not jam, has a dual trigger safety and uses a wide range of pins.

The warranty period is even better, as the manufacturer offers the seven-year warranty for the Bostitch model.

The reasons why this tool is not our top pick has to do with marring and countersinking.

Few pin nailers come with non-marring tips because of their bulky sizes.

It was harder than it needed to be to keep from marring the material.

Plus, it would not countersink pins in hardwoods such as oak and maple.

The differences between our top two picks are not so huge and both models can be said to be excellent choice.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Dual trigger safety
  • Light
  • Seven-year warranty period
  • Nice case
  • Belt hook


  • Leaves marks on softwood
  • Bad countersinking on hardwood
Check Price on Amazon

#3. Freeman PP123 23 Gauge Pin Nailer

Freeman PP123 23 Gauge Pin Nailer
Check Price on Amazon

The third place is taken by the Freeman pinner.

The positive sides of this pinner are that it weighs only three pounds, it is small, easy to use, and the manufacturer offers buyers a seven-year warranty.

What users like about this model are the reversible belt hook and the pin size selector switch.

The reasons why this model is only the third one are numerous.

Firstly, it does not have a wide range of pins, only 1/2″ to 1″.

And it is always good to have options no matter what you are doing.

The trigger safety works, but it has to be rotated to the side.

This results in no safety at all.

It is prone to jams more than it should be.

There were situations when it shot double nails or missed them.

You do not even get the case, so the storing of it is requires additional investment.

The only positive thing about this model is the price.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Amazing seven-year warranty
  • Reversible belt hook
  • Pin size selector


  • Awkward safety
  • Shoots double nails
  • Prone to jamming
Check Price on Amazon

#4. NuMax SP123 Pin Nail-Gun

NuMax SP123 Pin Nail-Gun
Check Price on Amazon

The NuMax SP123 Pin Nail-Gun uses 1/2″ to 1″ pins.

It has a reversible belt hook and rotating trigger safety, along with a decent pin size selector and these are all amazing features.

The negative sides are numerous.

Firstly, buyers get only a one-year warranty on the gun body and 30 days on wearable parts.

This is not satisfactory and proves that the company has no faith in this tool.

Secondly, the firing pin is prone to jamming and breaking.

Even though so many users have been complaining on this issue, NuMax is not willing to fix this.

Finally, the tool misses and shoots double nails which user claim that is happening right out of the box.

If you buy this model, you will feel very disappointed.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Reversible belt hook
  • Light


  • Awkward safety
  • Warranty
  • Firing pin sticks and breaks
  • Jamming
Check Price on Amazon

#5. Makita AF353 Pinning Nailer

Makita AF353 Pinning Nailer
Check Price on Amazon

We have expected much more from Makita, but it seems that they failed to make a good product when it comes to gauge pin nailers.

There are not so many positive things to be said about this model.

A good thing about it is that it is light weight.

Users also said that the case was good, but that is not enough to make this model better positioned.

The tool is prone to jamming which is a huge problem with pinners.

Those who used it claim that it jams the first time out of the box.

Pins are not shot correctly and it has an internal problem with the plunger breaking down.

Makita offers a three-year warranty on this pinner, but what they need to do is to improve the design flaws.

We suggest that you avoid this model, as you will only be wasting your time and money.

Check current price on Amazon >>


  • Case


  • Prone to jamming
  • Do not shoot pins correctly
  • Missed pins
  • Bad pin feed
  • Plunger breaks
Check Price on Amazon

23-Gauge Pin Nailers: The Ultimate Buying Guide

Our suggestion is to always check other people’s opinion before buying certain tool.

The same is with gauge pin nailers.

You should always keep in mind what you are trying to accomplish with your project or work and get the nailer which will be up to the task.

Pinners are often used in place of wood glue and how efficient model you will need depends only on you.

But we are here to tell you what to think about when purchasing a pin nailer.


Which features make this tool the good one?

The first thing that a good pinner should have is the widest possible range of pins.

The wider the range is, the more projects it can cover and you can be working on.

Plus, the good tool must handle hardwoods without leaving pins sticking up.

Its performance should be ideal, without jamming or misfiring.

And, as with all power tools, the unit should have good safety mechanisms, being that . a good product is one that does not put you in danger.

These are some of the factors that affect the functionality and efficiency of the tool.

I think I got it, what are my options?

You are aware that there is a number of options available, and if you think that these above mentioned models are not for you, you can always do your own research and get another one.

What you need to consider is what size pins you want for your project and that you need to possess an air compressor for pneumatic pinenrs.

Also, we need to suggest using plenty of oil so as to prevent jamming.

Gauge Pin Nailers


Among all the nailers mentioned, our top choice is the Hitachi NP35A pin nailer.

Being that we had only one drawback to mention – the flimsy case, which had nothing to do with the pinner itself, we assure you that buying this model would not be a wrong decision.

The best for the money model is the Freeman PP123 pin nailer, designed for those people on a budget, or for those who will use it occasionally around the house.

After you have read these reviews, you can pick your pinner with confidence and be sure that you made the right choice.

I hope you liked my article about 23-Gauge Pin Nailers, if so, please share or comment.

Leave a Comment

Get information about programs near you or online.